Flat vs Clipless Pedals: Which Should You Use?
Efficiency, confidence and convenience compared.
At a glance
- Best for
- Riders deciding on their first pedal upgrade
Research-based guide compiled from manufacturer documentation and published standards. Not hands-on tested by Medell.
"Clipless" is confusing: these are the pedals you clip into. The name comes from replacing old toe clips.
Clipless pedals
Advantages
- +Secure connection to the pedal
- +Consistent foot position
- +Popular for road and longer rides
Disadvantages
- −Requires specific shoes and cleats
- −Learning curve for clipping out
- −Less convenient for walking (road cleats)
Flat pedals
Advantages
- +Work with everyday shoes
- +Easy to put a foot down
- +Great for commuting and skills practice
Disadvantages
- −Foot can slip off in rough terrain without good shoes
- −Less fixed foot position
SPD vs road cleats
Two-bolt mountain-bike style cleats (such as SPD) are recessed in the sole, so shoes are easier to walk in. Three-bolt road cleats offer a larger platform but are awkward to walk in.
Making the switch
- Set the cleat release tension to the lowest setting at first.
- Practise clipping in and out on grass or against a wall.
- Unclip early when approaching junctions.
- Expect a slow fall or two; most riders have one while learning.
Frequently asked questions
Do clipless pedals make you faster?
They give a secure, consistent foot position, which many riders prefer for long rides. Fitness and comfort still matter far more for speed.
What shoes do I need for flat pedals?
Shoes with flat, grippy soles work best. Running shoes with soft, curved soles can slip.
Can I use clipless pedals for commuting?
Yes. Two-bolt mountain-bike style cleats are recessed in the sole, making shoes easy to walk in.
The Medell. Letter
New rides, workshop guides and reviews, in your inbox.
Free. Every two weeks, never daily. One-click unsubscribe. See our privacy policy.
Keep reading
Tire Width and Pressure: A Primer
The trend towards wider tires and lower pressures, explained without the marketing. How to choose a starting pressure.
Road vs Gravel vs Hybrid: Which Bike Should You Choose?
Road, gravel and hybrid bikes overlap more than marketing suggests. How they differ in tires, gearing and position, and which suits your riding.
What to Bring on a Long Bike Ride: The Checklist
A practical checklist of what to carry on long rides: repairs, food, water, money, ID and phone, and how to pack it all.